Weekly In-Store Cupcake Menu

This is the menu to use if you would like an assortment of flavors in your order. These are also the flavors that we have in our store at our counter, for purchase.  There are no minimum order requirements for these flavors, meaning you may order or pick up any amount of any flavor, in either our regular sized cupcakes or mini cupcakes!  If you are hosting a large party, meeting, event, or wedding, you may also consider our catering menu (see menu tab on our front webpage) however there are higher minimum order requirements per flavor on that menu.  Enjoy!

check back frequently, our menu changes weekly!


  • The Cream City – Vanilla Bean

Vanilla bean cupcake topped with our fluffy and delicious vanilla buttercream, both made with organic 100% real Madagascar-bourban vanilla extract, and garnished with vanilla vermicelli.

  • *The Shorewood – Vanilla Salted Caramel

Vanilla cake with butterscotch chips, filled with soft caramel filling, topped with our silky caramel buttercream, sea salt, raw sugar, & pecans.

  • The Lake Park – White Chocolate Raspberry

Vanilla cake with red raspberry marbling throughout. Topped with white chocolate cream cheese buttercream, a fresh raspberry, & white chocolate drizzle.

  • The Eastsider – Chocolate

Deep, dark chocolate cake with Guittard cocoa and chocolate, decadently creamy chocolate buttercream, garnished with delicious little chocolate crispearls… a chocolate-lover’s delight!

  • *The Third Ward – Peanut Butter Cup

Chocolate cake with Reese’s peanut butter cup chunks baked in, topped with our fluffy and amazing peanut butter buttercream, chocolate drizzle, & a chunk of Reese’s cup on top.

  • The Tuxedo – Chocolate/Vanilla Marble

Delicious chocolate and vanilla marble cake, filled with white chocolate cream cheese filling, then dipped in our rich dark chocolate ganache and finished with a white chocolate drizzle!

  • The North Shore – Red Velvet

Beautiful color with amazing flavor! This classic red velvet cupcake is topped with our silky cream cheese buttercream frosting. A match made in heaven!

  • The Downtowner – Carrot Cake

Moist and spiced, our carrot cake is made from freshly grated carrots and contains no filler ingredients such as coconut, raisins or pineapple. We top it with our divine cream cheese buttercream and a piped carrot in vanilla buttercream. (Does not contain nuts, but recipe includes nutmeg)

  • The Cudahy Tower:  White Chocolate Strawberry

It’s back!  Our vanilla cake with freshly sliced strawberries baked in, topped with either our white chocolate cream cheese buttercream, or our freshly pureed strawberry buttercream, garnished with a freshly strawberry and a white chocolate drizzle.

  • The Blood Orange:

Moist vanilla cake with pieces of blood orange baked in; topped with freshly squeezed blood orange buttercream and a slice of candied blood orange.

  • Pineapple Cream Cheese:

Moist vanilla pineapple cake, topped with our cream cheese-based pineapple buttercream, and garnished with a fresh piece of pineapple!

  •  Easter cupcakes:

Choose from two designs, available in either chocolate or vanilla cake; we have The Nest, or The Rabbit Hole to choose from!



*contains nuts or nut butters